Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of the included studies and patients

From: Rheumatoid arthritis and COVID-19 outcomes: a systematic review and Meta-analysis

Study ID, year, county

Study design; Study settings; Study duration

Number of participants in the study

Age of RA cohort

Female/male in RA cohort

COVID-19 outcomes reported

Ferri C et al., 2021; Italy

Observational multicenter study; Telephone survey; NS

1641 ASD patients with

695 RA patients

(63 ± 13) a

518/177

Prevalence of COVID-19

Freites N et al., 2020; Spain

Prospective observational study; Single tertiary Hospital; 1 March 2020 to 24 April 2020

123 AIRD–COVID patients with 50 RA patients

NS

NS

Risk of hospitalization

Mena V et al., 2020; Spain

Cross-sectional observational study; HRUM Emergencies; March 13 to April 12, 2020

1537 IAD patients with 13 RA patients

NS

NS

Death

Soldevila-D et al., 2020; Spain

Cross-sectional study; Hospital del Mar; September 2019 to March 2020

2544 IMID patients with 538 RA patients

NS

424/114

Prevalence of COVID-19

Alzahrani et al., 2020; Saudi Arabia

Retrospective study; Single tertiary care center; March 2020 to November 2020

47 RD patients with 25 RA patients

NS

NS

Severe COVID-19

Annamalai et al., 2020; India

Multi-center retrospective observational study; Six tertiary care centers; April 01, 2020 to October 15, 2020

85 RD- COVID patients with 44 RA patients

NS

NS

Hospitalization

Attauabi M et al., 2021; Denmark

Population-based cohort study; The Danish COVID-IMID cohort; January 28, 2020 to

September 15, 2020

71,733 IMID patients with 13,015 RA patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Bachiller-Corral et al., 2021; Spain

Retrospective single-center observational study;

Ramóny Cajal Hospital; March 1, 2020

to April 30, 2020

4592 IRD patients with 1708 RA patients

NS

NS

Hospitalization; Risk of hospitalization

Belleudi et al., 2021; Italy

Retrospective cohort Study; Regional administrative healthcare databases; NS

65,230 IMID patients with 20,299 RA patients

64 (52–75) b

15,184/5115

Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of death

Bower et al., 2021; Sweden

Cohort study; Swedish nationwide multiregister linkages; March–September 2020

110,567 IJD patients with 53,455 RA patients

69 (57–77) b

39,022/14,433

Risk of hospitalization; risk of ICU; Risk of death

Cordtz et al., 2021; Denmark

Cohort study; the linkage of several Danish nationwide registers; March 1 to August 12, 2020

29,440 RA patients

67.3 (56.7–75.7) b

20,990 /10,101

Death; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of severe COVID-19

Fernandez-G et al., 2021; Spain

Observational longitudinal study;

Single tertiary hospital in Madrid; March 1 to April 15,2020

3951 IRD patients with

1486 RA patients

NS

NS

Risk of hospitalization

Florence et al., 2021; France

Cohort study; Lille University Hospital; February 24 to April 17, 2020

694 IRMD patients with

213 RA-COVID-19 patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19; Severe COVID-19; Death

Gamboa-C et al., 2021; Peru

Cohort follow-up; Hospital Nacional Guillermo Almenara Irigoyen-EsSalud; March to November 2020

1148 ARDs patients with

169 RA patients; 75 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Guillaume et al., 2021; France

Observational monocentric cohort study; Adolphe de Rothschild Foundation Hospital; Apr 17 to Nov 2, 2020

459 IMID patients with

149 RA patients

NS

NS

Risk of COVID-19

Jung et al., 2021; Korea

Cross-sectional study; Nationwide COVID-19 cohort database by the Korea National Health Insurance Corporation; NS

35 RA-COVID patients,121 controls

NS

NS

Severity of COVID-19; Admission to ICU; Death; Risk of COVID-19; Risk of death

Naderi et al., 2021; Iran

Multicenter cohort-based observational study; Rheumatology clinics of academic hospitals of Isfahan; April and July 2020

954 RD patients with 215 RA patients;9 RA-COVID patients

51.09 (52 [43–60]) c

175/40

Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization; Death; Admission to ICU

Pileggi et al., 2021; Brazil

Cross-sectional analysis; Web‐based platform using telephone calls; March 29 to May 17, 2020

5166 RD patients with 402 RA patients;16 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Raike et al., 2021; USA

Retrospective cohort study; US multicenter research network (TriNetX); NS

9730 RA patients

(61.1 ± 15.3) a

7280/2450

Hospitalization; Admission to ICU; Death; Severe COVID-19; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of severe COVID-19; Risk of admission to ICU; Risk of death

Saadoun et al., 2021; France, Germany, Italy, Portugal, Spain, and the UK

Multicenter cross-sectional study;

Six tertiary referral centers in France, Germany, Italy, Portugal, Spain, and the UK; June 7 to Dec 8, 2020

3136 IMID patients with 891 RA patients;39 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Sarzi-P et al., 2021; Italy

Multicenter retrospective study; Italian regions of Lombardy and Marche; March 15 to April 23,2020

10,260 RD patients with 5373 RA patients;23 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Shobha et al., 2021; India

Prospective multicenter noninterventional longitudinal ongoing study; 14 specialist rheumatology centers across Karnataka; March 2020 to August 10, 2020

3807 RD patients with 1964RA patients;12 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Hasseli et al., 2021; Germany

Prevalence study; German COVID-19 registry for IRD patients;30th March to 16th November 2020

104 RA-COVID-19 patients

NS

NS

Hospitalization; Death

Batıbay et al., 2021; Turkey

Prevalence study; Gazi University Hospital; July to December 2020

320 IRD patients with 109 RA patients;6 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19; Death

Alsaed et al., 2022; Qatar

Single-center retrospective matched cohort study; A medical center; March 2020 to March 2021

141 ARD patients with 57 RA patients

NS

NS

Severe COVID-19; Risk of severe COVID-19

Assar et al., 2022; Iran

Prevalence study; Emam Reza and Golestan Hospitals; Feb 18 and Aug 22, 2020

1000 RD patients with 371RA patients; 78 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19

Becetti et al., 2022; Qatar

Cross-sectional study; Telephonic survey; April 1 to July 31, 2020

700 ARD patients with 260 RA patients; 34 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Curtis et al., 2022; USA

Retrospective cohort study; The Optum COVID-19 EHR dataset; February 1 to December 9, 2020

2306 RA-COVID patients

61 (19–89) b

1795/511

Hospitalization; Admission to ICU; Death; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of admission to ICU; Risk of death

Eder et al., 2022; Canada

Population-based, matched cohort study; The health administrative data; January 1 to July 31, 2020

134,964 RA patients

NS

NS

Risk of hospitalization

Figueroa-P et al., 2022; USA

Retrospective, comparative, multicenter cohort study; Mayo Clinic and Mass General Brigham in the USA; March 1, 2020 to June 6, 2021

582 RA patients

62 (14) a

421/161

Hospitalization; Death; Severe COVID-19; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of severe C OVID-19; Risk of death

Gomides et al., 2022; Brazil

Cross-sectional analysis; ReumaCoV- Brazil Registry; May 24, 2020, to January 31, 2021

489 RA patients

(53 ± 12) a

443/46

Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization

Gracia et al., 2022; Spain

Cross-sectional survey; Google form platform; April to October 2020

1526 AD patients with 46 RA patients;2 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Marozoff et al., 2022; Canada

Population-based matched cohort study;

British Columbia; February 6, 2020 to August 15,2021

6279 ARD patients with 2067 RA patients;

60.1 (18.3) a

1445/622

Risk of admission to ICU

Oztas et al., 2022; Turkey

Cohort study; Rheumatology outpatient clinics of Istanbul University-Cerrahpasa and Istanbul University; June 1 to September 1, 2020

89 RA patients; 4 RA-COVID patients

(53.9 ± 10.3) a

73/16

Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19; Hospitalization

Patil et al., 2022; India

Cohort study; 14 specialist rheumatology centers across Karnataka and one center in Kerala; April-December 2020

9212 AIRD patients with 4558 RA patients; 120 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of death

Rorat et al., 2022; Poland

Retrospective real-world study; The SARS Ter national database; 1 March 2020 and 31 January 2022

136 RA patients

NS

NS

Death

Sonaglia et al., 2022; Italy

Observational study; The province of Udine, Italy; September 2019 to November 2020

936 RA patients; 16 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Valladales-R et al., 2022; Colombia

Observational study; A health care institution; 1 April 2020 to 31 May 2021

2566 RA patients; 130 RA-COVID patients

61.9 (53.3–69.4) b

2080/486

Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization; Admission to ICU; Death

Wang et al., 2022; China

Cohort Study; The Health Improvement Network; February 2020 to September 2020

17,268 RA patients; 42 RA-COVID patients

(64.9 ± 13.5) a

12,295/4973

Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19

Yue et al., 2022; USA

Retrospective analysis; Optum EHR database; February 1, 2020 to March 3,2021

6108 RA patients

(61.5 ± 14.8) a

4714/1394

Risk of severe COVID-19

Li et al., 2022; UK

Cohort study; UK primary care database; December 8, 2020 to October 31, 2021

15,901 RA patients

(64.8 ± 13.7) a

11,258/4643

Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization; Death; Risk of COVID-19; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of death

Eder et al., 2023; Canada

Population-based, matched cohort study; Adult residents from Ontario, Canada; January 2020 to December 2020

493,499 IMIDs patients with 134,964 RA patients; 1349 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19

Geng et al., 2023; China

Prevalence study; A tertiary hospital in Beijing; December 8, 2022 to January13, 2023

2005 AIIRDs patients with 290 RA patients;228 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19

Jain et al., 2023; India

Prospective, non-interventional longitudinal cohort study; 15 referral rheumatology centers; Apr-Dec,2021

2969 AIRD patients with 129 RA patients

NS

NS

Risk of COVID-19; Risk of death

Khalaf et al., 2023; USA

Retrospective cohort study; The National Inpatient Sample (NIS) database; 2020

21,175 RA patients;

68d

15,458/5717

Risk of death

Rizzi et al., 2023; Italy

Prospective cohort; NS; October to December 2021

17 RA patients; 2 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19

Sarı et al., 2023; Türkiye

Prevalence study; İstanbul Fatih Sultan Mehmet Training and Research Hospital; July 2020 and January 2021

71 RA patients; 14 RA-COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19; Severe COVID-19

Scirocco et al., 2023; Italy

Retrospective, observational design; The national CONTROL-19 Database; March 26, 2020 to March 1, 2021

524 RA patients; 131RA-COVID patients

60.6 (13.1) a

389/135

Prevalence of COVID-19

Singh et al., 2023; USA

Cohort study; Database; January 1,2020 and September 16,2021

69,549 RA patients; 22,956 RA-COVID patients

61.00 (51.0, 71.0) b

17,492/5464

Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization; Admission to ICU; Death

Svensson et al., 2023; Denmark

Cohort study; Danish national registers; March 2020 to January 2023

30,919 RA patients; 13,011RA-COVID patients

52.1(40.3–63.8) b

21,895/9024

Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of death; Risk of Severe COVID-19

Tsai et al., 2023; Taiwan

Retrospective cohort study; the US Collaborative Network in TriNetX; January 1, 2018 and December 31, 2022

7284 RA patients; 753 RA-COVID patients

NS

5908/1376

Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization; Death; Severe COVID-19

Zamora-A et al., 2023; Philippines

Prevalence study; The Global Rheumatology Alliance registry; March 2020 to August 2021

164 IRDs patients with 25 RA

NS

NS

Risk of hospitalization; Risk of death

Bagheri-H et al., 2023; Iran

Retrospective cross-sectional study;

Ali-Ibn-Abi-Talib Hospital, Rafsanjan University of Medical Sciences; NS

200 RA patients;34 RA-COVID patients

NS

140/60

Prevalence of COVID-19

Abdulnaby et al., 2023; Egypt

Multicenter case-control study; Cairo University Hospitals; September 2020 and February 2021

66 RD patients with 32 RA patients;

NS

NS

Severe COVID-19

Armağan et al., 2023; Turkey

Single-center retrospective study; Ankara City Hospital Rheumatology Clinic; May to December 2021

98 ARD patients with 62 RA patients;14 RA- COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Nair et al., 2023; India

Prevalence study; A tertiary care center from South India; October 2019 to May 2021

76 RA patients;4 RA- COVID patients

NS

NS

Prevalence of COVID-19

Anand et al., 2023; USA

Cohort study; Veterans Health Administration electronic health records; January 1, 2020 to September 30, 2022

1355 RA-COVID patients

NS

280/1075

Severe COVID-19; Risk of severe COVID-19

Davis et al., 2024; USA

Retrospective case-control; The National Inpatient Sample database; January 1 to December 31, 2020

21,545 RA-COVID patients

68.75 (0.20) a

15,711/5834

Risk of death

Embaby et al., 2024; Egypt

Prevalence study; Cairo University hospitals and private rheumatology centers; The start of pandemic in 2019 till 30 June 2022

300 RA-COVID patients

(48.92 ± 12.1) a

187/13

Severe COVID-19; Death

Cordtz R et al., 2022; Denmark

Cohort study; Several Danish nationwide registers; January 1 to October 5, 2021

81,818RA patients;1942 RA-COVID patients

NS

58,233/23,585

Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization

Le M et al., 2023; Belgium

Longitudinal prospective monocentric study; Hospital Erasme (Brussels, Belgium); April 2021 and February 2022

79 RA patients;7 RA-COVID patients

61.0 (52.5–68.0) b

63/16

Prevalence of COVID-19

Mahdavi et al., 2021; Iran

Cross-sectional study; Tabriz University of Medical Sciences; 14 December 2020 to 14 March 2021

128 RA-COVID patients

(52.3 ± 13.9) a

107/21

Hospitalization; Admission to ICU; Death

  1. ASD inflammatory autoimmune systemic diseases, AIRD autoimmune inflammatory rheumatic diseases, IMIDs immune-mediated inflammatory diseases, IAD inflammatory articular diseases, RD rheumatic diseases, IRDs inflammatory rheumatic diseases, IJDs inflammatory joint diseases, IRMD inflammatory rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases, ARDs autoimmune rheumatic diseases, UK United Kingdome, USA United States of America. NS not specified.
  2. aMean with standard deviation; bMedian with IQR; cmean (median [IQR]); dMean