From: Rheumatoid arthritis and COVID-19 outcomes: a systematic review and Meta-analysis
Study ID, year, county | Study design; Study settings; Study duration | Number of participants in the study | Age of RA cohort | Female/male in RA cohort | COVID-19 outcomes reported |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ferri C et al., 2021; Italy | Observational multicenter study; Telephone survey; NS | 1641 ASD patients with 695 RA patients | (63 ± 13) a | 518/177 | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Freites N et al., 2020; Spain | Prospective observational study; Single tertiary Hospital; 1 March 2020 to 24 April 2020 | 123 AIRD–COVID patients with 50 RA patients | NS | NS | Risk of hospitalization |
Mena V et al., 2020; Spain | Cross-sectional observational study; HRUM Emergencies; March 13 to April 12, 2020 | 1537 IAD patients with 13 RA patients | NS | NS | Death |
Soldevila-D et al., 2020; Spain | Cross-sectional study; Hospital del Mar; September 2019 to March 2020 | 2544 IMID patients with 538 RA patients | NS | 424/114 | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Alzahrani et al., 2020; Saudi Arabia | Retrospective study; Single tertiary care center; March 2020 to November 2020 | 47 RD patients with 25 RA patients | NS | NS | Severe COVID-19 |
Annamalai et al., 2020; India | Multi-center retrospective observational study; Six tertiary care centers; April 01, 2020 to October 15, 2020 | 85 RD- COVID patients with 44 RA patients | NS | NS | Hospitalization |
Attauabi M et al., 2021; Denmark | Population-based cohort study; The Danish COVID-IMID cohort; January 28, 2020 to September 15, 2020 | 71,733 IMID patients with 13,015 RA patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Bachiller-Corral et al., 2021; Spain | Retrospective single-center observational study; Ramóny Cajal Hospital; March 1, 2020 to April 30, 2020 | 4592 IRD patients with 1708 RA patients | NS | NS | Hospitalization; Risk of hospitalization |
Belleudi et al., 2021; Italy | Retrospective cohort Study; Regional administrative healthcare databases; NS | 65,230 IMID patients with 20,299 RA patients | 64 (52–75) b | 15,184/5115 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of death |
Bower et al., 2021; Sweden | Cohort study; Swedish nationwide multiregister linkages; March–September 2020 | 110,567 IJD patients with 53,455 RA patients | 69 (57–77) b | 39,022/14,433 | Risk of hospitalization; risk of ICU; Risk of death |
Cordtz et al., 2021; Denmark | Cohort study; the linkage of several Danish nationwide registers; March 1 to August 12, 2020 | 29,440 RA patients | 67.3 (56.7–75.7) b | 20,990 /10,101 | Death; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of severe COVID-19 |
Fernandez-G et al., 2021; Spain | Observational longitudinal study; Single tertiary hospital in Madrid; March 1 to April 15,2020 | 3951 IRD patients with 1486 RA patients | NS | NS | Risk of hospitalization |
Florence et al., 2021; France | Cohort study; Lille University Hospital; February 24 to April 17, 2020 | 694 IRMD patients with 213 RA-COVID-19 patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19; Severe COVID-19; Death |
Gamboa-C et al., 2021; Peru | Cohort follow-up; Hospital Nacional Guillermo Almenara Irigoyen-EsSalud; March to November 2020 | 1148 ARDs patients with 169 RA patients; 75 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Guillaume et al., 2021; France | Observational monocentric cohort study; Adolphe de Rothschild Foundation Hospital; Apr 17 to Nov 2, 2020 | 459 IMID patients with 149 RA patients | NS | NS | Risk of COVID-19 |
Jung et al., 2021; Korea | Cross-sectional study; Nationwide COVID-19 cohort database by the Korea National Health Insurance Corporation; NS | 35 RA-COVID patients,121 controls | NS | NS | Severity of COVID-19; Admission to ICU; Death; Risk of COVID-19; Risk of death |
Naderi et al., 2021; Iran | Multicenter cohort-based observational study; Rheumatology clinics of academic hospitals of Isfahan; April and July 2020 | 954 RD patients with 215 RA patients;9 RA-COVID patients | 51.09 (52 [43–60]) c | 175/40 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization; Death; Admission to ICU |
Pileggi et al., 2021; Brazil | Cross-sectional analysis; Web‐based platform using telephone calls; March 29 to May 17, 2020 | 5166 RD patients with 402 RA patients;16 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Raike et al., 2021; USA | Retrospective cohort study; US multicenter research network (TriNetX); NS | 9730 RA patients | (61.1 ± 15.3) a | 7280/2450 | Hospitalization; Admission to ICU; Death; Severe COVID-19; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of severe COVID-19; Risk of admission to ICU; Risk of death |
Saadoun et al., 2021; France, Germany, Italy, Portugal, Spain, and the UK | Multicenter cross-sectional study; Six tertiary referral centers in France, Germany, Italy, Portugal, Spain, and the UK; June 7 to Dec 8, 2020 | 3136 IMID patients with 891 RA patients;39 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Sarzi-P et al., 2021; Italy | Multicenter retrospective study; Italian regions of Lombardy and Marche; March 15 to April 23,2020 | 10,260 RD patients with 5373 RA patients;23 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Shobha et al., 2021; India | Prospective multicenter noninterventional longitudinal ongoing study; 14 specialist rheumatology centers across Karnataka; March 2020 to August 10, 2020 | 3807 RD patients with 1964RA patients;12 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Hasseli et al., 2021; Germany | Prevalence study; German COVID-19 registry for IRD patients;30th March to 16th November 2020 | 104 RA-COVID-19 patients | NS | NS | Hospitalization; Death |
Batıbay et al., 2021; Turkey | Prevalence study; Gazi University Hospital; July to December 2020 | 320 IRD patients with 109 RA patients;6 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19; Death |
Alsaed et al., 2022; Qatar | Single-center retrospective matched cohort study; A medical center; March 2020 to March 2021 | 141 ARD patients with 57 RA patients | NS | NS | Severe COVID-19; Risk of severe COVID-19 |
Assar et al., 2022; Iran | Prevalence study; Emam Reza and Golestan Hospitals; Feb 18 and Aug 22, 2020 | 1000 RD patients with 371RA patients; 78 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19 |
Becetti et al., 2022; Qatar | Cross-sectional study; Telephonic survey; April 1 to July 31, 2020 | 700 ARD patients with 260 RA patients; 34 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Curtis et al., 2022; USA | Retrospective cohort study; The Optum COVID-19 EHR dataset; February 1 to December 9, 2020 | 2306 RA-COVID patients | 61 (19–89) b | 1795/511 | Hospitalization; Admission to ICU; Death; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of admission to ICU; Risk of death |
Eder et al., 2022; Canada | Population-based, matched cohort study; The health administrative data; January 1 to July 31, 2020 | 134,964 RA patients | NS | NS | Risk of hospitalization |
Figueroa-P et al., 2022; USA | Retrospective, comparative, multicenter cohort study; Mayo Clinic and Mass General Brigham in the USA; March 1, 2020 to June 6, 2021 | 582 RA patients | 62 (14) a | 421/161 | Hospitalization; Death; Severe COVID-19; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of severe C OVID-19; Risk of death |
Gomides et al., 2022; Brazil | Cross-sectional analysis; ReumaCoV- Brazil Registry; May 24, 2020, to January 31, 2021 | 489 RA patients | (53 ± 12) a | 443/46 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization |
Gracia et al., 2022; Spain | Cross-sectional survey; Google form platform; April to October 2020 | 1526 AD patients with 46 RA patients;2 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Marozoff et al., 2022; Canada | Population-based matched cohort study; British Columbia; February 6, 2020 to August 15,2021 | 6279 ARD patients with 2067 RA patients; | 60.1 (18.3) a | 1445/622 | Risk of admission to ICU |
Oztas et al., 2022; Turkey | Cohort study; Rheumatology outpatient clinics of Istanbul University-Cerrahpasa and Istanbul University; June 1 to September 1, 2020 | 89 RA patients; 4 RA-COVID patients | (53.9 ± 10.3) a | 73/16 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19; Hospitalization |
Patil et al., 2022; India | Cohort study; 14 specialist rheumatology centers across Karnataka and one center in Kerala; April-December 2020 | 9212 AIRD patients with 4558 RA patients; 120 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of death |
Rorat et al., 2022; Poland | Retrospective real-world study; The SARS Ter national database; 1 March 2020 and 31 January 2022 | 136 RA patients | NS | NS | Death |
Sonaglia et al., 2022; Italy | Observational study; The province of Udine, Italy; September 2019 to November 2020 | 936 RA patients; 16 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Valladales-R et al., 2022; Colombia | Observational study; A health care institution; 1 April 2020 to 31 May 2021 | 2566 RA patients; 130 RA-COVID patients | 61.9 (53.3–69.4) b | 2080/486 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization; Admission to ICU; Death |
Wang et al., 2022; China | Cohort Study; The Health Improvement Network; February 2020 to September 2020 | 17,268 RA patients; 42 RA-COVID patients | (64.9 ± 13.5) a | 12,295/4973 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19 |
Yue et al., 2022; USA | Retrospective analysis; Optum EHR database; February 1, 2020 to March 3,2021 | 6108 RA patients | (61.5 ± 14.8) a | 4714/1394 | Risk of severe COVID-19 |
Li et al., 2022; UK | Cohort study; UK primary care database; December 8, 2020 to October 31, 2021 | 15,901 RA patients | (64.8 ± 13.7) a | 11,258/4643 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization; Death; Risk of COVID-19; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of death |
Eder et al., 2023; Canada | Population-based, matched cohort study; Adult residents from Ontario, Canada; January 2020 to December 2020 | 493,499 IMIDs patients with 134,964 RA patients; 1349 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19 |
Geng et al., 2023; China | Prevalence study; A tertiary hospital in Beijing; December 8, 2022 to January13, 2023 | 2005 AIIRDs patients with 290 RA patients;228 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19 |
Jain et al., 2023; India | Prospective, non-interventional longitudinal cohort study; 15 referral rheumatology centers; Apr-Dec,2021 | 2969 AIRD patients with 129 RA patients | NS | NS | Risk of COVID-19; Risk of death |
Khalaf et al., 2023; USA | Retrospective cohort study; The National Inpatient Sample (NIS) database; 2020 | 21,175 RA patients; | 68d | 15,458/5717 | Risk of death |
Rizzi et al., 2023; Italy | Prospective cohort; NS; October to December 2021 | 17 RA patients; 2 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19 |
Sarı et al., 2023; Türkiye | Prevalence study; İstanbul Fatih Sultan Mehmet Training and Research Hospital; July 2020 and January 2021 | 71 RA patients; 14 RA-COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19; Severe COVID-19 |
Scirocco et al., 2023; Italy | Retrospective, observational design; The national CONTROL-19 Database; March 26, 2020 to March 1, 2021 | 524 RA patients; 131RA-COVID patients | 60.6 (13.1) a | 389/135 | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Singh et al., 2023; USA | Cohort study; Database; January 1,2020 and September 16,2021 | 69,549 RA patients; 22,956 RA-COVID patients | 61.00 (51.0, 71.0) b | 17,492/5464 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization; Admission to ICU; Death |
Svensson et al., 2023; Denmark | Cohort study; Danish national registers; March 2020 to January 2023 | 30,919 RA patients; 13,011RA-COVID patients | 52.1(40.3–63.8) b | 21,895/9024 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Risk of COVID-19; Risk of hospitalization; Risk of death; Risk of Severe COVID-19 |
Tsai et al., 2023; Taiwan | Retrospective cohort study; the US Collaborative Network in TriNetX; January 1, 2018 and December 31, 2022 | 7284 RA patients; 753 RA-COVID patients | NS | 5908/1376 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization; Death; Severe COVID-19 |
Zamora-A et al., 2023; Philippines | Prevalence study; The Global Rheumatology Alliance registry; March 2020 to August 2021 | 164 IRDs patients with 25 RA | NS | NS | Risk of hospitalization; Risk of death |
Bagheri-H et al., 2023; Iran | Retrospective cross-sectional study; Ali-Ibn-Abi-Talib Hospital, Rafsanjan University of Medical Sciences; NS | 200 RA patients;34 RA-COVID patients | NS | 140/60 | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Abdulnaby et al., 2023; Egypt | Multicenter case-control study; Cairo University Hospitals; September 2020 and February 2021 | 66 RD patients with 32 RA patients; | NS | NS | Severe COVID-19 |
Armağan et al., 2023; Turkey | Single-center retrospective study; Ankara City Hospital Rheumatology Clinic; May to December 2021 | 98 ARD patients with 62 RA patients;14 RA- COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Nair et al., 2023; India | Prevalence study; A tertiary care center from South India; October 2019 to May 2021 | 76 RA patients;4 RA- COVID patients | NS | NS | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Anand et al., 2023; USA | Cohort study; Veterans Health Administration electronic health records; January 1, 2020 to September 30, 2022 | 1355 RA-COVID patients | NS | 280/1075 | Severe COVID-19; Risk of severe COVID-19 |
Davis et al., 2024; USA | Retrospective case-control; The National Inpatient Sample database; January 1 to December 31, 2020 | 21,545 RA-COVID patients | 68.75 (0.20) a | 15,711/5834 | Risk of death |
Embaby et al., 2024; Egypt | Prevalence study; Cairo University hospitals and private rheumatology centers; The start of pandemic in 2019 till 30 June 2022 | 300 RA-COVID patients | (48.92 ± 12.1) a | 187/13 | Severe COVID-19; Death |
Cordtz R et al., 2022; Denmark | Cohort study; Several Danish nationwide registers; January 1 to October 5, 2021 | 81,818RA patients;1942 RA-COVID patients | NS | 58,233/23,585 | Prevalence of COVID-19; Hospitalization |
Le M et al., 2023; Belgium | Longitudinal prospective monocentric study; Hospital Erasme (Brussels, Belgium); April 2021 and February 2022 | 79 RA patients;7 RA-COVID patients | 61.0 (52.5–68.0) b | 63/16 | Prevalence of COVID-19 |
Mahdavi et al., 2021; Iran | Cross-sectional study; Tabriz University of Medical Sciences; 14 December 2020 to 14 March 2021 | 128 RA-COVID patients | (52.3 ± 13.9) a | 107/21 | Hospitalization; Admission to ICU; Death |